Below will hopefully be a list of good, bad and interesting anime that I've stumbled across. Same rule as Netflix for interesting, 'Bad'/average and 'Interesting' will be put in the 'Interesting' category while 'Good' and 'Interesting' will just be marked Good.
Kore wa Zombie Desu ka? - Dude that became a zombie and then a magical girl.
Shokugeki no Soma (aka Food Wars) - Iron Chef as an Anime. The foodgasms get a bit much early on, but they tone it down as it goes on.
Yakitate!! Japan - Similar to Food Wars, but focused on baking. It ends abruptly in a way that suggests it suddenly lost funding and a lot of the puns are specific to Japanese but still good.
Ace Attorney - Based on the Ace Attorney games. If you enjoyed the games, or ever wanted to play them it's worth looking into.
Re:Zero kara Hajimeru Isekai Seikatsu - Groundhog day with loop after loop.
.Hack//Sign - The original 'guy stuck in a video game' anime. The games that follow on and the anime that you get with them is interesting.
Overlord - A guy who got stuck in a virtual reality game. Nothing unusual except he's an undead mage with a huge dungeon/castle.
Log Horizon - Another 'stuck in a game' anime. Focuses a little more on logistics and survival than most.
Yugioh Arc V - Like I said in my Netflix entry, pendulum is bullshit and the main characters deck is extremely convenient.
Tatakau Shisho The Book of Bantorra - "In a world where dead people are turned into books..." If that doesn't meet the definition of interesting almost nothing will.